gender research - hallas absense

Beattie’s challenge to Zimmerman and West

Geoffrey Beattie studied and recorded that within a conversation there were 557 interruptions within 10 hours of discussion. Zimmerman and West recorded 55 interruptions. Beattie also found that men and women interrupt an equal amount- an average of 34.1 men and 33.8 women. This made men interrupt more however not as much as Zimmerman and West shown.

John Grey's popular book 'Men are from Mars, Women are from Venus'

In the book, men and women differ in the language they use when communicating. The main points in the book and theories are:

• Language and communication matter more to women than men.
• Women are more verbally skilled than men
• Men focus about getting things done in the conversation. Men are more factual whereas women want to connect and make a relationship out of the conversation.
• Can lead to miscommunicating between the sexes and could cause misinterpretations

This book makes it seem like men are the bullies in the conversation and women only care about feelings and connecting with others. It is also patronising to men to read it as they sound like bullies too. This can also make women sound less ‘powerful’ than men because men want to get the conversation over with whereas women want to enjoy the conversation and enjoy it. Today, the sexes would be equal so I think the language is slightly diverged.

Mary Beard

She believes that men have more power over vocal compared to women and that women are not treated equally. This is because she thinks that women do not speak authoritative however men come across as ‘deep voiced with connotations of profundity’. Men also appear to always get the last word even if women come up with the ‘excellent suggestion’. In the old punch cartoon she talks about how younger children would be influenced by the behaviour and looks into how women speak in today’s society.

Dale Spencer

The research is based upon the book ‘Men made language’. She argues that men have more power over women over all societies and classes. They also believe that they are the dominant gender and disobedient women who fail certain tasks are then labelled as ‘frigid’ or abnormal’. This is also down to the low toned masculine tone of voice.

Dale Spencer and Pamela fishman challenges to other theories

Pamela- she conducted research upon young American couples by listening to 50 hours of pre-recorded conversations between them. She found that five out of the six subjects were going to graduate school. The subjects included feminists, were white or between the ages of 20-30. She mainly found the women’s language use a lot of tag questions such as ‘you know?’

Dale- she also looked into tag questions such as ‘isn’t it?’ however she believed that this was down to gaining conversational power.